“I never expected to become a dad at 40!” Jets’ Aaron Rodgers exclaimed tearfully, overwhelmed with joy as he and his wife, Shailene, welcomed their first baby.

The 29-year-old actress, who’s engaged to Aaron Rodgers, posted the simple black-and-white snap without any caption or context, leaving followers to wonder what it could all mean.Fans immediately began to questtion what Shailene was trying to tell them with her cryptic Instagram photo.

Many wondered if the baby is a friend of hers, or if it’s actually her own with fiance Aaron.

Others thought the photo of a newborn’s feet was possibly her way of teasing that she’s currently pregnant with her first child.

One confused follower asked on Twitter: “DID SHAILENE WOODLEY AND AARON RODGERS HAVE A BABY???”

Another questioned: “ummm whose baby is that on Shailene Woodley’s Instagram story????”

A third demanded answers, writing: “IS SHE A MOM? IS THAT A RANDOM BABY? WHO IS THAT? DID SHAILENE WOODLEY HAD A BABY AND NO ONE KNEW? I NEED SOME INFORMATION HERE”